Comparing this one to Market Spice’s Rum Butter, this one is a little sweeter and more candy-like in aroma. Sniffing it, I am also reminded of some of DavidsTea’s rooibos blends. Not sure if it’s a flavouring association (although in this case, hopefully, since the bases shouldn’t be similar!).
Flavourwise, it’s a bit astringent, but sweet and rummy-tasting. There is coconut in this one, and it does come through a bit – perhaps that’s part of the flavour association? I should compare this to coconut cream pie as well. Haven’t had that one in a while since my bad experience one day in the field (using uber crappy field station water), which turned me off all teas I had that day (Malted ChocoMate, Jane Austen Mafia, Coconut Cream Pie, Blueberry Rooibos).
Although this is an unintended comparison, in terms of a desserty flavoured black, I think I liked 52teas Pot O’ Gold better than either of these. And although this one is sweeter and more desserty, the base of Rum Butter is definitely more appealing. My choice however, might be Pot of Gold… (I should do a direct comparison with Rum Butter though, as those two are the most similar. I guess it’s because of the butterscotch flavouring being pretty similar to buttered rum). So, bonus for coconut haters!
Another downside of this one is more oily scum on the top – Rum Butter barely had any. It’s possible that it’s due to the coconut flakes, though.
Second infusion (96C/5min): tastes a bit sweet/buttered rummy, but not a lot of base tea. Not bad, not great.
Dropping the rating here; I had it quite high but really wasn’t enjoying it as much as I apparently had previously.
Preparation
Comments
I have been cold brewing this one (warm brewing in all honesty) and I find the creaminess comes out really well that way.
Haha just using lukewarm to a bit warmer water. I dont measure the temp exactly, but definitely around 60-70*c I would say and let it sit for a while… Then put it in the fridge after 30 min. I just find I get so much more flavour and creaminess out of the coconut
I have been cold brewing this one (warm brewing in all honesty) and I find the creaminess comes out really well that way.
Warm brewing?? Do explain!
Haha just using lukewarm to a bit warmer water. I dont measure the temp exactly, but definitely around 60-70*c I would say and let it sit for a while… Then put it in the fridge after 30 min. I just find I get so much more flavour and creaminess out of the coconut
Interesting. I should try it!