100

I recently opened the box of this I’ve been saving for the holidays, and I’ve already had several bags. The flavor is so buttery and delicious. It’s like an actual sugar cookie. I’m going to have to order some more boxes of this. I use two bags for 18 oz of liquid, and I add sugar, milk, and vanilla. It’s one of my very favorite teas. I’m sorry it gets so many negative reviews. It really does need those additions to make it great, but I don’t hold that against it because it brings the buttery flavor that I rarely see in a tea.

gmathis

Sugar Cookie has a sort of sentimental cult following around here! And indeed, it’s high time I had some!

AJRimmer

Stores near me sadly never have any, so I have to order it online. It’s so good!

gmathis

Locally, we usually get seasonal rack displays of holiday CS and, when we’re lucky, Bigelow flavors (Eggnogg’n is my favorite.)

Shae

This hasn’t been one of my favorites, but I’ll definitely be trying it now with the additions you recommend!

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

People who liked this

Comments

gmathis

Sugar Cookie has a sort of sentimental cult following around here! And indeed, it’s high time I had some!

AJRimmer

Stores near me sadly never have any, so I have to order it online. It’s so good!

gmathis

Locally, we usually get seasonal rack displays of holiday CS and, when we’re lucky, Bigelow flavors (Eggnogg’n is my favorite.)

Shae

This hasn’t been one of my favorites, but I’ll definitely be trying it now with the additions you recommend!

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

Profile

Bio

I’m an event planner who always has multiple mugs of tea beside me. Hobbies other than tea include board games, video games, cooking international dishes, science fiction, hiking, jigsaw puzzles, tap dancing, reading, listening to podcasts, and playing with my troublesome kitties.

Favorite flavors: dessert flavors, nutty, melon, mint, strawberry, anything rooibos-related.

Don’t prefer: Smoky, rosemary, savory flavors, floral (other than lavender), plain tea.

I always drink flavored tea, and preferably caffeine-free or black. I’ll try just about anything though! Let me know if you’re interested in a swap!

My ratings are kind of meaningless, but basically
90-100 pretty perfect
80-89 really good
70-79 good, but not the best
60-69 okay, but probably not for me
1-59 varying degrees of dislike

Location

US

Following These People

Moderator Tools

Mark as Spammer