200 Tasting Notes
Another foil-wrapped paper teabag of uncertain age, from the loose-ends bin of a local tea shoppe. Note that this is “Organic” EGS, not Harney’s standard EGS, and this is sold in paper teabags only, while the standard EGS is sold only in silken sachets or as loose leaf. Also, the ingredients differ between the two, “organic” being comprised of black teas from India, whereas the standard EGS is comprised of black tea, oolong tea, and white tea, and the description also mentions “silver tips” without explanation. So I created this new Steepster entry for the Organic EGS, since that is what I have. (The entry for standard EGS might be due for some revision, as the description on their website seems a bit different, though no one has added a note there in recent post-CoVid years.
I steeped the bag Western style in 8 oz. boiling spring water for 3 minutes. The dry leaf had a lovely bergamot aroma, and it had dissipated considerably by the end of steeping. This tastes to me like the quintessential Earl Grey. I loved it! The bergamot flavor was present and perfectly balanced with the malty assam tea base, both very tasty. Very slight astringency, as expected, and a lovely long finish that expressed both tea and bergamot. No bitterness, sourness, or stale cardboard notes. I have a second bag that I will steep for the recommended 5 minutes, and report back on what I find. Meanwhile I can fully recommend this organic earl grey supreme, and rate it as 91. [FOLLOWUP: 5 min. steep. Nicely strong tea, without loss of bergamot taste. Enhanced maltiness from the assam base black, without defects. Retained the long finish, and like the shorter steep, slurping and gurgling the lukewarm tea greatly enhanced the flavors and allowed the assam base to sing. Still just slightly astringent. So 3 min steep or 5 min steep, terrific tea either way is good!]. Among the best EG’s, in my opinion. (And I don’t care one bit about it being “organic” or not.)
Flavors: Astringent, Bergamot, Malty, Tea
Preparation
I haven’t had the organic version, but of all their plain Earls I like the Earl Grey Supreme best. Victorian London Fog and Diamond Jubilee are good but I don’t feel a need to keep them on hand. I am not usually a huge Earl fan unless the base is Chinese tea. I do like bergamot and other flavors combined, though, on most bases!
@ashmanra, I recall having one of H&S’ plain Earl Greys, but it was before I was making sip-notes and I wasn’t much experienced in the scope of their offerings. I also recently bought a tin of their Paris sachets, which is a jacked-up EG blend having an oolong component like the standard EGS, and you may have a note on if I search through the gazillion reviews of it here on Steepster. But I’ll def keep an eye open for Harney’s standard EGS to try it out! It’s also time for me to revisit Twinings EG, which got me through high school and which I mostly abandoned in 1981 when they switched from bergamot oil to bergamot flavoring, viewing it as a slipping of standards.
Paper teabag (in a sealed foil pouch) from a local tea shoppe bin of loose ends. Uncertain age. Nice citrus fragrance on the dry leaf. Steeped as directed: 3 min at 175°F. Resteeped once. Both were crystal clear amber liquids. I’m sure I’ve tasted this lemony-mediciney-lime peely flavor before, but I can’t recall where. I didn’t know what ginko (leaf? seed? wood?) tastes like, and I still don’t. For that matter, I couldn’t taste the base green tea, either. Maybe it’s just some nondescript shrub grown in someone’s backyard in East LA. Really, the citrus flavors overpower everything, and yet I could really see diggin’ this tea when I’m in the right groove, baby, ya know? That isn’t today. Can’t recommend, and rate as 50. I suspect stratification has segregated the tea and the lemongrass, because others have observed the reverse of me: green tea dominating the citrus! Or maybe their “flavorings” are out of control.
Flavors: Lemon, Lemongrass, Lime
Preparation
I bought this off the shelf at their store at 115 S. Walnut St, Champaign-IL. The dry leaf was a mix of inch-long needles and shorter, broken pieces, with a deep green colour. Steeped 2.5 grams of leaf Western style in a stainless steel infusion basket using 8 ounces of 170°F alpine spring water, for 60 seconds, with a re-steep of 90 s. The liquor was clear golden-yellow in appearance with a fragrance of mown grass and asparagus. Flavor notes included asparagus, edamame, chestnut, umami, and a hint of kelp and sweetness. It was delicious. There was only a slight astringency, and no bitter or sour elements. I’ll rate this as 81, the same as Adagio’s Sencha Premier, and recommend it, especially to those in central Illinois as a superb local business worthy of support.
Flavors: Asparagus, Chestnut, Edamame, Seaweed, Sweet, Umami
Preparation
I bought a box of Harney’s Japanese Sencha tea sachets (foil wrapped and nitrogen flushed) at a local tea store today, because they were sold out of dragon well. Steeped for 1.5 minutes in 170° water. The liquor was greenish gold in color, wonderfully aromatic, and tasted nutty, buttery, with notes of asparagus and edamame, and every bit as delicious as another major brand I’ve had recently. Re-steep was also delicious. I rate this as an 81, (same as Adagio’s) and would be happy to recommend and buy it again. I got no bitterness, no astringency, nothing harsh at all. I strongly recommend you avoid oversteeping!
Flavors: Asparagus, Butter, Chestnut, Edamame, Smooth
Preparation
Jasmine Yin Hao. Adagio.
Lot no. 90535. FB: n/a.
Recently received this single-serving portions-pouch of a terrific-sounding green tea, scented with Jasmine flowers, though the flowers themselves were absent from the blend. Prepared the full 3 g portion as directed, Western style: in 8 oz 180°F alpine spring water for 2.5 min. The liquor was a light amber hue, scented strongly of lovely jasmine, both the dry leaf and the infusion. It was a pleasure to drink, though except for a slight astringency, I could taste nothing of the green tea itself. I might as well have steeped a jasmine-scented empty teabag with a few mg of caffeine. I steeped a second infusion, re-using the leaf, hoping the jasmine element might be reduced sufficiently to permit appreciation of the Yin Hao, which by itself is said to be good for multiple infusions or gongfu style prep. Alas, though the jasmine was much weaker, I still could not discern notes from the green base, which I now conclude to be somewhat less than stellar. Really, after reading about the qualities of Yin Hao green tea, it was a disappointment to taste nothing of it. In the end, nothing set this apart from every other jasmine green tea I’ve had. If you like jasmine aroma and flavor, I can recommend this, just don’t expect more. I’ll rate it at 60 for being nice but unidimensional. Still better than drinking plain water!
Flavors: Astringent, Jasmine
Preparation
2005 Changtai “Bu Lang Mountain” Raw Pu-erh Tea Cake. Yunnan Sourcing USA.
The cake is loosely compressed and with only a little prodding 5 g. fell off the cake, enough for steeping. I gave it serial 30 s. infusions in 6 oz. alpine spring water at 195°F. after a 10 s. discarded wash in same. First steep was light amber liquor with soft fragrance of tea, flavors of aged wood, slight astringency and a drying sensation. Second was medium amber with stronger notes of same flavor profile. Some minerality and bitterness along the sides and back of my tongue. A soft, clean petrichor aroma, aftertaste with note of brazil nut and wheat bread and a caffeine kick. Third infusion was the same. For a twist, I turned the Fourth infusion into sweetened iced tea, which was quite tasty. My last infusion, the fifth, was much like the third in color and flavor, even though I’d increased the water to 8 oz., boiling, and steeped for 2 min. This was less tannic and had a smoother mouthfeel. This tea is still relatively young and I’m undecided whether to recommend or not. Overall I found it more of a challenge than a joy to drink, except when sweetened and iced. For now, I’ll only rate it at 50, but revisit in a year and see if it’s improving.
Flavors: Astringent, Bitter, Brazil Nut, Bread, Decayed Wood, Dry Leaves, Drying, Mineral, Petrichor, Tannic, Tea
Preparation
Not that it really matters in terms of what your brewing experience was like, but I don’t really think a 20ish year old sheng would be considered young anymore. There’s not really a hard a fast “rule” for when a pu’erh stops being young, but most forums/tea communitys/etc I’ve come across seem to have a general consensus that 8-10 years is no longer young. So it’s maybe more like it’s in the later portion of its awkward adolescence phase before “maturing”.
That’s fair, Ros. Especially given that Yunnan Sourcing describes it as having been “Aged in hot and humid Guangdong…”. So perhaps middle-aged is a better way to describe the chronology, regardless of my impression of its sensory maturity. But since I don’t think I’ve actually tasted anything over 35 years old, it’s hard for me to know how serious and properly maintained aging should impact flavor and fragrance. Shortcuts like storage in Taiwan or climate-controlled conditions outside of Yunnan or Burma are known to accellerate the process, vs. Kunming storage but, again, I just do not have the experience or finances to properly evaluate that.
This now, is the second half of the portions pouch I started on 2 d ago. No food yet this morning, though I just finished sipping a slightly brutal 20 yr old raw pu-erh, and this Darjeeling in contrast is striking! It feels in my mouth like a balm to sore taste buds. The gentle spring flower aroma, the sweet liquor with flavor notes of honey and a long finish of molasses, the hint of malt and dandelion flower, and a smoothness in the back of my throat. Light but refreshing, and I’m raising my rating to 79. Sometimes deprivation helps one appreciate what can be had. Darjeelings are redeemed.
Flavors: Dandelion, Floral, Honey, Molasses, Smooth, Sweet
Preparation
Ali Shan. Adagio.
Lot no. 85420. FB: n/a..
Recently got this single-serving portions pouch in a sample box, and it is said to be from Taiwan. Steeped as directed, Western style: the entire 3.8 g of rolled leaf in a stainless steel infusion basket with 8 oz. spring water at 195°F for 2 min. Produced a yellow liquor with a floral nose and buttery smooth floral flavor that included a note of perfume in the first re-steep. A very gentle tea, and the leaves appeared intact and fully expanded after the first re-steep. I noted many full single leaves, and a few sets of 2 or 3 leaves with or without a bud. Vigorous slurping and allowing the tea to crawl up my sinuses at the back of my tongue gave a more appreciable flavor. My overall impression, however, was of weakness. A fourth (final) infusion of the leaf at 205°F for 4 min. yielded a golden liquor with a similar aroma and flavor profile. I’ve enjoyed much more potent oolong flavors elsewhere, though this tea could go well with delicate foods and fruits, or done well by itself—possibly iced and sweetened. I detected grassy and spinach notes as the tea cooled during my session. A good, if basic, oolong, but not one to shop around for. Rating 70.
Flavors: Buttery, Floral, Grassy, Perfume, Spinach
Preparation
Spring Darjeeling. Adagio.
Lot no. 85535. FB: n/a.
Having been disappointed by a couple other Adagio Darjeeling’s, I approached this single-serving portions-pouch with trepidation. Received last month, so it’s fresh. For some reason, today I felt I’ve been drinking my teas a little bit over leafed, and so I’ve reduced the amount to 1.5 g per 8 oz. cup (which I feel better approximates the amount inside the pyramid sachets packed by various vendors) instead of my usual 2.5 or 3 g. And I’ve already had fully enjoyable cups, as such, of dragonwell and keemun this morning. No food yet. I noted that the leaf of this Spring Darjeeling was substantially broken (1 cm sized bits), yet a 3 minute Western style infusion produced a clear orange-amber liquor with a gentle, floral aroma. The flavor was a honeyed maltiness, without astringency, and a floral finish. Vigorous slurping increased my enjoyment and brought out other layers of savory wood and soft spiceyness. Overall a nice, gentle tea that was good to sip on this overcast, warm Independence Day (USA) morning. Did not attempt a resteep. I look forward to steeping the rest of the pouch tomorrow morning! Recommend with a rating of 74.
Flavors: Floral, Honey, Malt, Smooth, Spices, Woody