Norfür said

Scented/Flavoured Teas?

So I’ve been stocking up with TWG Teas for the past couple years, and I seem to have noticed that along side their “purer” offerings and blends, they’ve got a lot of scented blends. I’m not talking about teas with artificial flavourings here, I mean, I actually see strawberry chunks in the canister of Silver Moon tea. But what about the principle?

Now, I’m not really judging a specific category, and it might be some kind of weird bias popping up, but shouldn’t tea be allowed to stand on its own taste and merits?

Or is this some weird imaginary standard that I’ve got on my mind that one should learn to appreciate the subtleties in tea itself and purely tea-based blends, and that adding scents/flavourings to a tea is sort of “cheating” at the game. For example, I might not be very good at it yet, but I can definitely taste the difference between a Darjeeling Green, First Flush, and Second Flush (Second and Autumnal, I have more difficulty).

Wouldn’t it be, ah, “fairer” to the tea, to let it keep its own unique, different flavours, rather than “adulterating” it with unsubtle additives?

I was sort of disappointed when, after I tasted strawberries in this green tea I ordered at a cafe, I traced it back to their supplier (TWG, just down the hall), and found out that, instead of the green tea actually having notes of strawberry, it was in fact a strawberry blend.

I guess it’s my having the wrong expectations or something, I dunno. But what are your thoughts on scented/flavoured teas?

I mean, I guess they could be good for uhm, folks who enjoy a little something extra in their tea, I dunno. While I don’t necessarily think any less of them, the experience – nobody’s fault but my own, perhaps – left a pretty bad taste (heh) in my mouth.

13 Replies

People like to think of blended/flavoured teas as a largely Western thing but the reality is that you can trace blended/flavoured teas back to the Tang Dynasty (approx. 610 to 900) if not earlier where it’s well documented that the Chinese added things such as ginger, leek, mint, and orange peel to their tea.

So, I don’t think it should be surprising that things like scented or flavoured teas exist or are so prevalent in North American culture. I like to think of them as a great “gateway” to learning more about the natural flavour differences between different tea types due to processing methods or terroir. And after all, sometimes the things a tea is flavoured with are flavours that certainly wont ever naturally occur in tea leaf: things like birthday cake or cola flavoured teas. Those teas may not be everyone’s thing (and that’s perfectly ok) but it doesn’t make them, imo, any less valid as a way of drinking tea.

I think it just boils down to personal preference. There’s no wrong way to drink tea in my mind – make it however you like it!

EDIT: And I see now that you’re not located in North America so maybe some of my comments don’t apply so directly, but I think the general idea still rings true.

Login or sign up to post a message.

Another angle is the flavored teas appeal to non tea drinkers – that’s what gets them in the door. It’s fun, more familiar alternative to juice and soda. Some people stay there as they like flavored teas and there’s always people coming up with new things. Selling a strawberry black tea is an easier sell than a 2015 sheng pu’er to someone who’s barely had tea, let alone doesn’t own a gaiwan and such.

Even then, people like to experiment. All the time there’s people asking how to make their own blends and stuff.

I know there’s lots of snobbery, I too love pu’er and oolong that isn’t flavored, but at the same time it’s a different art to flavored teas. One could think a flavored tea just masks cheap tea or makes it more appealing, but I’ve had flavored tea that goes with the tea base to make it better, especially if you go buy from a smaller, handcraft tea seller.

Dustin said

Butiki did an impressive job of playing off the natural flavors of the tea when making blends. Is there anyone who has tea blending skills comparable to hers?

I can appreciate straight teas now, but couldn’t for most of my tea drinking life. Still, sometimes I just want a fun dessert in a cup!

LuckyMe said

Yup, flavored teas were the gateway to good quality straight tea for me. The subtleties of straight tea really takes a mature palette to appreciate and that develops over time.

While I lean towards straight tea now, I feel that flavored tea can be sublime IF done correctly. Unfortunately low quality, artificial tasting crap dominates the market and detracts from the truly artisanal blends that small vendors have to offer.

Login or sign up to post a message.

OMGsrsly said

I love both flavoured and unflavoured. But personally I’ve found the TWG flavoured teas to be REALLY extremely flavoured. Like, burn the lining of your nose when you sniff the canister strong. There are flavoured teas that are more delicate, or more in tune with the base tea that I like better. And then sometimes I just want an Earl Grey.

I also find flavoured teas tend to travel better in a thermos, since I still don’t have a great tea steeping set up at work.

Login or sign up to post a message.

I mostly drink herbal teas, so I might have a very different perspective, but one of the things that got me into drinking tea was the wide variety of interesting flavors. I see it kind of like cooking. Some foods stand on their own very well, but some taste much better when mixed with other foods or spices, and sometimes you get a really enjoyable interplay of flavors when you mix several foods together. Good tea can stand on its own, but additives can result in something interesting and unique, and maybe something you’ll like as well as, or even better than, the original product. A lot of blended tea is made from cheaper and lower quality tea. But that both makes it more accessible, and is a way to use up lower quality tea. But at the same time, you often get what you pay for.

Login or sign up to post a message.

I like straight teas. I like flavored teas. I like homemade mac and cheese. I like Kraft blue box. None of those things should concern anyone else or impact their personal philosophy on tea. Tea is a very personal thing and we each like what we like.

Login or sign up to post a message.

Oneironaut said

I’m inclined to agree. I think a lot of people are missing out by not drinking more straight teas, and in my experience the artificial flavorings (or natural/organic flavorings for that matter) have an off taste. That said, I still enjoy some jasmine tea occasionally, and I wouldn’t mind branching out into more flavored teas as long as they don’t have flavor oils in them.

Teavana was actually what got me into tea. I don’t drink it any more, but that store introduced me to the idea that tea could be a pleasant beverage, rather than the overbrewed lipton which was all I knew of tea before.

Norfür said

I didn’t really think of them as having an off taste. Except maybe for the peaches in TWG’s Grand Wedding. They gave me some teabag samples of that. It’s really overpowering.

Login or sign up to post a message.

I like to drink blended/ flavoured teas fairly often. Mostly- Earl Grey and variations. And floral/ fruit blends are nice too.

Login or sign up to post a message.

Norfür said

Wow, this is certainly a lot of feedback!

You’re right. If flavor/scent blends go back as far as ancient China, then to have them or not really is a matter of preference. Looking at it from the perspective of a gateway tea, or another addition to an already great brew, are also very valid ways to look at it.

We can have flavoured blends as something to get people started. Doesn’t even have to be fancy modern ones, we can have old time classics like Earl Grey. I remember Twinings Earl Grey was the first box of teabags I consciously bought (Unfortunately Twinings doesn’t sell loose leaf in my country). Before that time, my concept of tea was this sweet iced drink lol . Gotten past that stage now, of course, but I largely consider that to be the first step.

I guess it also depends on how the blend works out. OMG says the TWG’s flavour blends are reeeaaally flavoured. I don’t really think too much of how it overpowers the original taste. I mean if I want to taste strawberry in my Silver Moon, I want it pronounced. But I can see that it leads to the question of whether I want to drink tea with some hints of strawberry, or hot strawberry juice. I’d definitely want to try the former.

Anybody here have recommendations for nice subtle blends? Is Butiki a good example of that?

Login or sign up to post a message.

AllanK said

The thing about flavored teas is they have to be done right. A well done flavored tea will taste great. A badly done one will taste terrible. Lupica is an example of a company that does flavored right. They have a Chocolate Strawberry Puerh that is incredible even to a fanatic about straight puerh tea.

Norfür said

You mean, this one?

https://usa.lupicia.com/category/select/cid/285/pid/9676

Now you’ve got me interested. Regular puerh is deep and complex enough. What more with the addition of chocolate and strawberry, eh? :3

Login or sign up to post a message.

Login or sign up to leave a comment.