612 Tasting Notes

drank Bread Pudding Chai by The Devotea
612 tasting notes

Giddy ‘cause I made this today for afternoon tea with R, bothering with the whole stovetop fuss ’cause it’s Valentine’s Day and a Friday, and finally I have made some chai at home as good as the one at my favorite local Indian restaurant’s! It’s subtler per the bread pudding focus than traditional Indian chai, but delicious. The smell is wonderful. Yes!

4 teaspoons Breading Pudding Chai
16 oz milk (I think part of the secret is to make sure the milk’s got some fat…you’re already going to the trouble and adding sweetener too, so!)
1 Tablespoon honey

On the stove top at the lowest setting for about 15 to 20 minutes, never letting it really simmer. I went by feel for when to stop, based on color, thickness, and taste testing. Strained and voila. So good!

Robert Godden

Yes on the fat! Full cream or 2% works but less than that is a dud.
And we’re really pleased how well this worked for you, and were thrilled with your message!

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

drank Two Tigers by The Devotea
612 tasting notes

Fitting considering I spent last night watching, among other things, a documentary on tigers (while my little black cat snuggled on my blanketed stomach no less) and today’s Valentine’s Day (also Lupercalia and the full moon, woot). Just like the other Devotea blends I’ve tried, smooth as all get out while still full of deep black tea flavor. No trace of bitterness here. Agree with some other reviews about there being an earthy minerality, but it’s never funky because much like Finbarr’s Revenge everything stays very clean tasting as well. I get the smoothness and depth of the Chinese tea at the front, and the Indian qualities come out at the back, as it cools. Surprisingly friendly brew, probably a lot more pleasant going down than actually encountering two tigers, one from China and one from India, ambushing you! It did get me wired though, more than the others for some reason.

Now to go prepare for Valentine’s Day festivities. Dorkily enough we’re going to the museum a couple blocks from our house to participate in the Internet Cat Video Festival, ha.

Preparation
205 °F / 96 °C 3 min, 0 sec 2 tsp 16 OZ / 473 ML
TeaLady441

That sounds really fun!

Robert Godden

Thanks for allowing our tea to share a snippet of your life. That’s my favourite kind of drinker review!

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

drank Chocolate Mint by Harney & Sons
612 tasting notes

Ohmahgosh little hand-held wand milk frother, where have you been all my life?! I resisted buying you because if Amazon is to be believed you break at the drop of a hat, but let’s be real here: the roundabout methods for frothed milk (heating a half empty mason jar in the microwave then shaking carefully while praying glass doesn’t explode everywhere from stress + thermal shock, fun times), while not terribly complicated, were enough extra steps I pretty much never bothered. Plus the froth from those methods while nice was never mindblowingly special. But you! I just fish you out of a drawer like a fork, don’t even have to plug you in, push a button to let you do your thing for 30 seconds and voila, magical, really tightly bubbly, tickly joyous milk froth for anything. Rinse you off with a dab of soap under the faucet, push you again to spin dry, and that’s it. I am in love. Even if you DO break in 3 months you’ll be worth the $7, egads.

It feels wrong to even review the tea here, because the froth discovery has me all twitterpated, ha. But it’s good. As I suspected, much like the plain Chocolate from Harney, which I like (it keeps lingering in the back of my mind, that dreamy Thin Mint aroma). I could have either of these made double strength with frothy milk plunked in my big 16 oz cup and call it a night on the couch (much healthier than devouring half a box of Thin Mints, no?). Tea and finding all sorts of new ways to enjoy it has truly kept me sane while holed up this winter.

Preparation
205 °F / 96 °C 4 min, 0 sec
Courtney

I always forget about my milk frother. Maybe since I so rarely drink milk, but for matcha I could use it!

ifjuly

that’s actually what finally motivated me—i placed my first red leaf order in anticipation of a switch to matcha lattes from breakfast teas for my first-thing-in-the-morning drink once the weather finally warms up (i’m being optimistic!). but it makes evening tea feel more like dessert for sure too. yay!

TeaBrat

Oh I want one!

ashmanra

I bought the Aerolatte. I think it was a little less than $20 with my coupon for Bed, Bath, and Beyond. I got one for my daughter, too. We use them sooooo much for matcha lattes and to froth hot chocolate. I think they are both over a year old now.

keychange

I want one! I want one! and I love your tasting notes!

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

drank Chocolate by Harney & Sons
612 tasting notes

For a chocolate-and-nothing-else flavored tea this is pretty good! The smell is excellent dry, steeping, and finished. But as is true with most chocolate teas, it leaves one a little wanting not because it’s a bad specimen but it’s just…it’s not just good ol’ straight up chocolate. You know? (And then you’re like well, duh.) Still, nice cup. While it has a slight raspiness to let you know there’s tea in there, the tea is certainly not the star, just a ho-hum backdrop for lots of milk chocolate aroma. I have a feeling the chocolate mint’s going to be an improvement, as I can practically hallucinate peppermint right into this cup with a lovely tingle on the tongue, yum. Smells like a thin mint.

ETA I resteeped this for 5 minutes and it was quite good, smoother and still very chocolate-y. I’m digging it! Nice caffeinated option when I don’t want the intense richness of cacao tisanes or saltysugarbombed packet-y Choco-Late. The first tea that tastes like the liquified coating of yeah, Thin Mints. Not quite gourmet truly intense cacao drink nor fake sugary wax either, but the coating on mainstream bon bons. Nice.

Flavors: Chocolate

Preparation
205 °F / 96 °C 3 min, 0 sec 1 tsp 8 OZ / 236 ML

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

drank Lord Petersham by The Devotea
612 tasting notes

This one feels even stronger in some ways than the other two breakfast blends I’ve tried so far from The Devotea. It’s smooth though, just like they were; the body feels less like a coat but there’s a welcome slight leaf bitterness that works with the smoothness. I might like 1910 a skosh more for the surprising flavors at the end of its sip, but this is nice too. The color in the cup is gorgeous, clear but deep, a warm brown smoothly burnished with a bit of ruby. Breakfast blends! Along with after dinner Assams you are getting me through this endless winter and for that, many thanks.

Preparation
205 °F / 96 °C 3 min, 0 sec
keychange

You’re right about this winter feeling endless.

Robert Godden

So glad you are also enjoying this. It’s our most popular tea in America.

mrmopar

20 inches of snow so far here, traffic is slam stopped everywhere.

Terri HarpLady

That’s a lot of snow!
I’m happy to report that the snow is melting in St. Louis, which is good because I hate moving my harp in the snow!

mrmopar

Settled out at 26 inches of snow. Blah lots of shoveling.

Terri HarpLady

Or you can just sit around & drink tea :)

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

drank Cacao Tea by Herbal Infusions
612 tasting notes

As I was hoping, this does indeed get better when you way overleaf it (I tripled my standard amount!), provided you like the bittersweetness of dark chocolate. It still feels a little thin bodied though the flavor is for sure amped up. Next time I’ll try making it super strong and then cutting it with cream. Right now, and as it cools upon resteep, it’s like taking an 80%+ cacao bar of chocolate, melting it down, adding milk or cream but not sweetener (it’s silky, rich, and intense but not terribly sweet), and drinking it in liquid form.

Even getting the prep just right I can tell this isn’t going to replace American Tea Room’s Choco-Late for me. That one’s very “cheap packet hot chocolate for little kids, complete with the intense granular salt-sugariness” nostalgic junky comfort food while this one, worked out to its best prep, is going to be more grown up, richer and more solid, well, cacao beany. There’s a place for both sorts of course, but the dirty truth is I probably will appreciate the former more when I reach for it because it’s, I dunno, an instant trip down memory lane without having to keep actual crappy packets of Swiss Miss around indefinitely going stale for just those moments. This kind of thing just makes me want to go back to Asheville and drink a mug of modern day Xocolatl from French Broad or something, or whip up some liquid Dagoba Xocolatl. Plus, that stuff’s intense no matter how you shake it; a little gourmet thimble’s worth and your taste buds and belly both feel stuffed to the brim.

I’m not conveying myself clearly; ugh it’s late. I guess what I mean is, when prepped right this does a bang up job at being that rich, thick, intense cacao bean drink one imagines in tiny cups. But part of me is more grateful that the cheap Swiss Missy substitute version of cacao husk tea exists. That both do is pretty great though, of course.

Preparation
205 °F / 96 °C 5 min, 0 sec 3 tsp 8 OZ / 236 ML

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

drank Bread Pudding Chai by The Devotea
612 tasting notes

Generalized chai rant/rambling: I can’t for the life of me figure out what it is about me and chai. I should like it, I always want to like it, I love the spices involved…but it never quite clicks into place. I sense I’m just not doing it right, whether prepared like a standard tea, done with all the effort on the stovetop with milk, or simply cut with creamy sweet additions. Like I’m expecting some magical extra quality like the kind in Indian restaurants, something buttery smooth AND magically warming beyond usual tea, and it never comes or it comes in mere hints or mangled with gross aftertastes or other effects. Hm.

This comes really close though, close enough I think if I can prep it just right I’ll have found my peace. I’ve noticed perplexingly enough while I favor strong spicing in cooking and cocktails in chai I seem to like when things are a little gentler. Herbal Infusions’ Creme Brulee Chai is quite gently spiced as these things go, more on the creamy sweet end of the spectrum as opposed to hotly spiced, and this is also on that end, for the better in my opinion. The smell is fantastic, possibly the best aroma of a chai I’ve tried so far. It really does evoke bread pudding, that rich creamy slightly boozed up haze of baked cinnamon and nutmeg. And it is good made like a standard tea. Then I go mucking things up adding some raw sugar and dairy and it loses its punch and a sticky sickly aftertaste shows up I’m pretty sure wouldn’t otherwise. Eurgh. I’m going to try giving it the latte treatment next time, no added sweetener, and see if that works well. Definitely among my favorite chais tried so far, but I just feel like I could hit perfection if I keep tweaking prep somehow…so close…

Preparation
205 °F / 96 °C 3 min, 0 sec
K S

I have pretty much given up on ever learning to love chai. I tolerate it and sometimes even like it (Simple Loose Leaf Winter Chai) but apparently I will never love it. Better luck to you.

Terri HarpLady

I love chai, & there is a sample of this one, waiting for the end to my sipdown madness…taunting me…

I also don’t always have the best of luck making it at home, however. I know it would be more delicious made with real milk, which I can’t have, & if I steep the spices in simmering ‘other milks’ (like coconut or almond, or even better yet, a mix of both), It takes forever to go through the strainer! I guess I could try putting the spices in one of the paper tea steeping bags, but I feel that would confine them. Sometime I make a really strong concoction in water & then cut in the hot milk after straining, but it always ends up seeming weak…sigh…

ifjuly

yeah, it sounds like we have similar experiences Terri! alas. it can be SO GOOD, i know it can, when i get indian for lunch it always is—but i can’t figure out how to make it super good but also not a big PITA late at night to mess with. hrm.

Robert Godden

There are so many variables that you can make chai twice the same way and get a different result. Even though I usually don’t take milk or sugar, here’s how I do this one: First clear your mind of “cup of tea” . This is a dessert treat. Then put a double helping of the chai in a saucepan and add 250mls of milk and two teaspoons of sugar or even better, honey. Put it on the lowest heat setting and allow it to come up to drinking temperature , if that takes ten minutes or so, all the better. Strain and drink.

ifjuly

thanks for the advice!

ifjuly

Robert!! I just wanted to let you know I made the rest of my sample per your instructions today for afternoon tea with the husband since it’s Friday and Valentine’s Day, and it was super delicious! The first chai I’ve made that was as good as my favorite local Indian restaurant’s. Thank you so much!

Robert Godden

:) . It’s great the way that worked out!

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

This one’s lighter and more floral, a teensy bit Darj-y in some ways. I liked it, and it resteeped ok just like all the other Assams from Capital I’ve tried. But I prefer the darker, heavier, more intense ones like the Borsapori and Duflating. Definitely a case of individual affections defining how worthwhile this cup feels, and how that’s personal and varies, though. Lovely for what it is. Would make a solid afternoon tea.

Preparation
205 °F / 96 °C 3 min, 0 sec

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

drank Finbarr's Revenge by The Devotea
612 tasting notes

Oooh. This is silky slick as oil (without actually being oily, phew!), easy going down but nice and strong too. I love when you get that strength but without the usual corresponding tannic roughness. And I’m getting that mysterious lurking marine quality Terri describes (and loving it).

I had this first thing with cold leftover cashew chicken (not the most traditional, but still the breakfast of champions). Really nice. Thinking of hanging with the Queen shortly (“rain outside so a book and the Queen, peachy keen” popped in my head and well, who am I to argue?).

Preparation
205 °F / 96 °C 3 min, 0 sec 2 tsp 16 OZ / 473 ML
Sil

So jealous of you guys…I so need to get a devotea order in…

Sami Kelsh

That sounds really, really good. As does the breakfast.

keychange

as does the queen!

Robert Godden

Thanks for taking the time to record your thoughts.
Speaking of Things Queenly, we have just launched “Queen Adelaide Superior Breakfast Tea” in Australia and two of our blends (‘Love of My Life’ and ‘Seaside Rendezvous’ – both AUST only sadly) are named after Queen songs

ifjuly

yes, i am jealous of the australian residents who get to try those! esp. seaside rendezvous, sounds great!

ifjuly

and haha Sami Kelsh, good to know i’m not the only one who thinks leftover take-out-style (even when homemade) chinese is the best breakfast!

Robert Godden

@ifjuly Seaside Rendezvous is one of my favourites, but to be honest, not a big seller. We created it for a cause. Here’s the long-winded story of its creation. http://thedevotea.teatra.de/2013/01/21/reality-check-no-thanks/

ifjuly

oh man, great story! it’s a shame you couldn’t get a civet to go to the seasize rendezvous. in a bowler hat. but i guess they probably don’t like water…

ifjuly

teeth though. teeth would be provided if there’d been a civet there. especially if you tried putting a hat on him/her.

Robert Godden

For completeness/self-indulgence, here is a link to how we came up with Finbarr’s Revenge, the tea this post was originally about! http://thedevotea.teatra.de/2013/05/29/real-people-real-tea-devotea-origins-part-v/

ifjuly

ah, i’d been wondering who finbarr was. also, your blog is a really enjoyable read! i just finished the one about the duchess of bedford and it was fun too. thanks for sharing!

Robert Godden

Thank you. What other teas of our do you have, if any, that might be on your tasting radar?

ifjuly

i got the black tea sampler, plus bread pudding chai. i am going to try lord petersham tomorrow as my morning tea (i know it’s billed as an afternoon blend, but i like to wing it), looking forward to it! also especially excited about two tigers and persian princess.

Robert Godden

My wife, the legendary Lady Devotea, insists the Lord Petersham is a breakfast blend. It works fine. I am heading to our warehouse to blend Bread Pudding Chai today; it’s good in a cup but also in 10 kilo mounds!

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

This one’s good too, but I was surprised checking now to see it’s Capital Teas’ second priciest Assam because to me it reads as great in the ways the others are—namely the fantastic smoothness—but much more straightforward, with a less complex network of flavors (maybe I just can’t detect them though…I am a subtaster and all that). The flavor is tasty, there just aren’t as many notes, less transformative interplay. This is a softer tea, but don’t get me wrong, it still has a deep sweet flavor. It would make a good first thing cup because of its relative simplicity and first rate smoothness; instead of a harsh tannic pucker you’d greet the day with the palate equivalent of warm soft fuzzy blankets.

Preparation
205 °F / 96 °C 3 min, 0 sec

Login or sign up to leave a comment.

Profile

Bio

“…you can never know everything about anything, especially something you love.”
-Julia Child on food and cooking, and I think it applies to tea as well!

note: i am currently taking a break from swapping/mail of any kind as money is rather tight. i apologize! i do love to swap but i can’t afford to right now. hopefully in a month things will change.

my cupboard includes any tea i’ve ever owned, including things i’ve sipped down, in order to facilitate swaps with people and keep a record—this way i don’t get redundant samples/order duplicates to try. if you are interested in swapping, i have a separate ever-updated list of teas i actually have on hand i can PM.

i like strong, rich blacks (including some choice old skool CTCs); juicy-fruity flavored green blends; buttery chinese greens; light floral oolongs; flavored oolongs (how sacrilegious!); earl greys; smoky blends; second flush muscatel darjeelings; verdant’s straight oolongs steeped in a gaiwan (mind altering!); anything from laoshan village it seems.

favorite notes include lavender, bergamot, violet, fennel, cardamom, melon, honey, sandalwood, smoke, nuts, roasty/toasty stuff, malt, wood, leather, creamy lemon, steamed rice, artichoke, garden-sweet snap veggies, earth/soil, forest and wet bark, and mushroom.

notes i generally can’t stand (at least in tea) include jasmine, rose (ok in small doses but i often find it overpowering and then everything just smells like musty old lady perfume), astringent apple (and general fruitiness really unless it’s with green tea), and chamomile (unless i’m congested or tired).

my current favorite tea vendors are butiki and harney and sons. i’ve also found some delicious teas and/or had good customer service experiences with the following companies: capital tea ltd., the devotea, verdant, mandala, golden moon, teavivre, lupicia, taiwan tea crafts, yezi tea, den’s tea, the tea merchant, norbu, fauchon paris, tao tea leaf, zen tea, fortnum and mason, townshend’s tea, joy’s teaspoon, new mexico tea company, persimmon tree, teajo teas, whispering pines, della terra, upton imports, mariage freres, samovar, justea, teabox, american tea room, steven smith, steap shoppe, utopia tea, and andrews and dunham damn fine tea. when i’m at the grocery store my “you could do worse” brands include stash, bigelow, tazo, taylors of harrogate, whittard of chelsea, and pg tips. and it’s a fact: you can’t make classic southern sweet tea without luzianne.

top picks, fall 2013

black:
verdant zhu rong yunnan black
verdant laoshan black
thepuriTea hong jing luo (no longer available :( )
thepuriTea red dragon pearl (no longer available :( )
mandala morning sun
golden moon honey orchid
verdant golden fleece
taiwan tea crafts red jade
yezi tea zheng shan xiao zhong “scotch” tea
capital tea borsapori estate assam tgfop1 (spl)
butiki khongea golden tippy assam
butiki giddahapar darjeeling extra special
upton imports fikkal estate
golden moon sinharaja
harney and sons new vithanakande
persimmon tree vintage black
teajo teas black manas
justea kenyan black
harney and sons kangaita op

morning blends:
butiki the black lotus
harney and sons queen catherine
harney and sons eight at the fort
harney and sons big red sun
harney and sons scottish morn
golden moon irish breakfast
harney and sons irish breakfast
utopia tea english breakfast
fortnum and mason breakfast blend (needs milk!)
andrews and dunham double knit blend
steven smith no. 25 morning light
butiki irish cream cheesecake

earl greys and scented afternoon blends:
teajo teas silky earl grey
harney and sons viennese earl grey
upton imports lavender earl grey
american tea room victoria
lupicia earl grey grand classic
harney and sons tower of london
tao tea leaf cream earl grey
zen tea earl grey cream
della terra earl grey creme
upton imports season’s pick earl grey creme vanilla
upton imports baker street afternoon blend
harney and sons russian country
della terra professor grey
verdant earl of anxi

flavored black:
herbal infusions moose tracks
american tea room brioche
steap shoppe cinnamon swirl bread
della terra oatmeal raisin cookie
butiki nutmeg cream
kusmi caramel
david’s tea brazillionaire
lupicia banane chocolat
butiki hello sweetie
fauchon paris raspberry macaron
butiki blueberry purple tea
herbal infusions marshmallow snowflake earl grey
herbal infusions creme brulee chai

pu erh:
mandala loose and luscious lincang 2007 shu/ripe pu erh
mandala special dark 2006 shu/ripe pu erh

oolong:
verdant shui jin gui wuyi oolong
verdant hand-picked early spring tieguanyin
butiki 2003 reserve four season oolong
harney and sons formosa oolong
tea merchant silk dragon
golden moon coconut pouchong
zen tea coconut oolong
american tea room coconut oolong
teavivre taiwan jin xuan milk oolong
butiki flowery pineapple oolong
butiki lychee oolong
lupicia momo oolong supergrade
butiki strawberry oolong
butiki pumpkin milkshake darjeeling oolong
52teas tiramisu oolong

green:
verdant laoshan bilochun green
verdant autumn harvest laoshan green
tao tea leaf hou kui
harney and sons tencha
harney and sons gyokuro
new mexico casablanca
butiki with open eyes
american tea room nirvana
joy’s teaspoon mahalo
den’s tea pineapple sencha
harney and sons tokyo
butiki potato pancakes and applesauce
butiki holiday eggnog and pralines
den’s tea organic genmaicha with matcha
golden moon hojicha

white:
butiki cantaloupe and cream
butiki champagne and rose cream

no caf:
harney and sons soba buckwheat
butiki birthday cake
della terra lemon chiffon
52teas strawberry pie honeybush
butiki mango lassi
joy’s teaspoon italian dream
butiki coconut cream pie rooibos
butiki peppermint patty
persimmon tree mint chocolate chip rooibos
art of tea velvet tea
fusion teas chocolate cake honeybush
american tea room choco-late
steven smith no. 40 bon bon
townshend’s tea dark forest chai
utopia tea decaffeinated earl grey cream

sleep aid/medicinal/therapeutic:
new mexico extra sleepy bear
stash white christmas
verdant ginger sage winter spa blend
samovar turmeric spice
butiki the killer’s vanilla guayusa

coldsteeped wonders:
whispering pines manistee moonrise
harney and sons fruits d’alsace
utopia tea berkshire apple and fig
culinary teas peaches and cream
butiki peach hoppiTea
butiki ruby pie
whispering pines gingerade

besides tea

born in seoul, raised in new england and upstate new york, went to college in pittsburgh, currently in memphis with an eye toward philadelphia, portland, or asheville eventually.

i like cats, most beverages really (i also like good freshly roasted coffee, craft beer, wine, whiskey and gin-based cocktails, and soda/soft drinks like agua fresca), art (mainly writing but also visual and music) and critical theory, feminism/genderqueer politics, historiography, statistics, children’s literature and librarianship, travel, and food/cooking. also have recently gotten into weightlifting (mark rippetoe and stumptuous!) and sprint training (HIIT, plyometrics) and i love it.

Location

Memphis, TN

Website

http://facebook.com/ifjuly

Following These People

Moderator Tools

Mark as Spammer