Is Genmaicha an acquired taste?

Do you have to really love umami? Is it something else? Enlighten me! (Disclaimer: I like it, and never had a moment when I didn’t.)

31 Replies
cookies said

I loved it from my first try as well. But I understand why some people may find a savory tea odd. It can be a bit brothy.

Login or sign up to post a message.

LuckyMe said

As someone who only recently acquired a taste for genmaicha, I would say it depends on one’s tastebuds and how it’s steeped. I’m not a fan of roasty teas to begin with so I didn’t care for its burnt taste. It wasn’t until I got my hands on some good quality genmaicha with matcha and steeped at lower temperatures that I started liking it. I think the matcha helps takes the edge off the bitterness and gives it a fuller flavor. Because ordinary genmaicha doesn’t taste like much else besides toasted grain.

Dexter said

And those of us who like the roasted grain flavors – and not so much the green tea part of it – probably would do better with just a standard quality without the matcha.
It’s all about personal preference – to each their own.
I don’t like green tea – love genmaicha. :))

Equusfell said

I’m the same way. Adding matcha takes ‘burnt’ and turns it into ‘nutty’. I like the tea when I’m looking for something mild and comforting. Also, the base green should never be marine or seaweed-like. It just turns it into miso soup for me!

Login or sign up to post a message.

It’s an interesting idea, if some type of tea is an acquired taste more than others. One hears matcha described in this way, but of course someone could love decent matcha the first time they tried it, or maybe even lower grade matcha, or maybe something related like matcha ice cream could serve as a gateway. I would think tea mixed with roasted rice would be the opposite, the kind of thing people would like right away, and then maybe move away from once they were exposed to other teas, but any of that would really depend on individual preference.

Login or sign up to post a message.

It is an acquired taste. I first had it at a Japanese teahouse. Liked the roasted grain/ nutty flavours. Though sometimes it tastes more like noodle soup.

Rasseru said

I think it tastes like soup too.

You can get Chazuke https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chazuke which is green tea over rice. Its really good. Genmaicha falls in that category for me

Login or sign up to post a message.

Lynxiebrat said

The 2nd Genmaicha I had was wonderful, the 1st was…ehh. So I don’t think it was quite an acquired taste for me.

Login or sign up to post a message.

The actual question about it being an acquired taste corresponds to someone needing to try it several times to like it, right? This relates to how someone wouldn’t like coffee, or beer, or scotch at first, but once they get used to these unusual taste ranges they would like them, or at least might or might not. I found genmaicha to be very approachable at first, so per my experience maybe more a good introduction, easy to like on the first try, or the opposite of an acquired taste. I mentioned matcha because people have claimed the opposite for that, that it is an acquired taste, not as natural for people to like it on the first try, or for Wuyi Yancha type oolongs, perhaps for other tea types as well.

Rasseru said

Yes, thats the right definition for ‘acquired taste’

I liked it first time. Puerh I’m still on the fence – this has been the longest ‘acquired taste’ for me, I still dont like shou that much

Hahaha Rass!!! I’m feeling ya! I’ve tried a couple of pu-erhs now… and I’m wondering if it’s gonna end up being one of those “been there, done that, ain’t going back” things… I’m really glad to be on the sheng olympics so I can try a bunch to help me decide. :)

Rasseru said

I’m sure there are really good ones around – I’ve had some aged sheng that I like, and young sheng I knock back one after another.

Ripe though. It is weird. Butttttt, thats also funny because i’ve just finished breakfast which consisted of Natto & konnyaku rice, and Natto is definitely ‘acquired’ :)

Ahhh, I grew up eating natto so I love it. But I understand how it throws folks off.

Login or sign up to post a message.

Hojicha was an interesting opposite experience for me. I tried a couple versions at the same time and thought they were great, a new expression of tea I could really get into. By the time I had finished all of it I thought it was nice but I’d probably not get around to ever trying it again any time soon.

Login or sign up to post a message.

Ubacat said

I’ve had times when I crave this tea and want it frequently. Then I will go long periods of time when I don’t have it. There is a strange attraction to it.

Zennenn said

Me too, I go through phases when I crave it. But I either really want it or not at all.

curlygc said

Same here.

Login or sign up to post a message.

I’ve only tried a couple genmaicha teas, but since I tend not to care for green tea, I didn’t really like them. I did really enjoy Verdant’s Black Chocolate Genmaicha, and I’ve toasted rice on my own and enjoyed that. So I think it really is the green tea, or the way the flavors of the green tea and the rice interact.

Uniquity said

That is my experience as well. I don’t like green tea (it’s been 5 years and it still hasn’t become enjoyable) but I loved the black chocolate genmaicha. I like the toasted rice, but I would rather pair it with a black tea or roasted oolong.

Login or sign up to post a message.

Brian said

i know its not for me. too food tasting for me.

Login or sign up to post a message.

Login or sign up to leave a comment.