MissB was kind enough to send me a box full of decaf teas after I mentioned I had to be careful with caffeine for awhile and this is the first tea I pulled out. If their all as good a this one then that box of teas is worth it’s weight in gold! Drinking this tea is like drinking a really good hot coco, so silky smooth and sweet! The distinction between peanut and peanut butter cup is apt in that it doesn’t taste of actual peanut butter, but more like the filling in peanut butter cups. I can see why that might detract from this blend for some people, just as some people only eat Lindt chocolate and not Hershey’s. But me, I very much enjoy what they’ve done here. The cheesecake doesn’t come through very much for me, perhaps in the mouth feel or overall creaminess, but not as a flavor note. A tasty (caffeine free) treat for a rainy night just like this!